Shocking story from NBC News with this sick and unprecedented headline:
“Trump transition
team compiling list of current and former U.S. military officers for possible
courts-martial”
Trump wants to nail all the officers involved in the
chaotic 2021 U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, even though independent
reviews have blamed both Trump and Biden while GOP only blames Biden.
The Trump transition team is compiling a list of senior
current and former U.S. military officers who were directly involved in the
withdrawal from Afghanistan and exploring whether they could be court-martialed
for their involvement, according to a U.S. official and a person familiar with
the plan.
Officials working on
the Trump transition are considering creating a commission to investigate the
2021 withdrawal from Afghanistan, including: (1) gathering information
about who was directly involved in the decision-making for the military, (2) how
it was carried out, and (3) whether the military leaders could be eligible for
charges as serious as treason, the U.S. official and person with knowledge of
the plan said the person with knowledge of the plan said and added: “They’re
taking it very seriously.”
The Trump transition
team did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Matt Flynn, a former deputy assistant secretary of defense
for counter-narcotics and global threats, is helping lead the effort, the
sources said. It is being framed as a review of how the U.S. first got into the
war in Afghanistan and how the U.S. ultimately withdrew.
Trump has condemned the withdrawal as: “A humiliation and the most embarrassing day
in the history of our country.”
BELOW ARE THE FACTS AND HISTORICAL TIMELINE VIS-À-VIS THE ORIGINAL TRUMP
DEAL AND THE REASON BIDEN CHANGED IT BASED ON KEY RESEARCH.
Below clearly stated
is the rational reason early on about the chaos during the Afghanistan pullout
– that shortly thereafter, and how and why President Biden got it on track …
think of the details below explained in common sense and logical rational
military thinking reported
on here from the SLATE story
with this headline (excellent report by Fred Kaplan. My key emphasis are noted in RED)
the subject:
“We
Now Know Why Biden Was in a Hurry to Exit Afghanistan”
The GOP does not want to talk about this part of the that moment
in September 28, 2021 Senate hearing on the withdrawal from Afghanistan when it became clear why
President Joe Biden decided to get the troops out of there as quickly as
possible.
That moment came when
General Mark Milley, Chairman of the JCS, explained why he and the other Service
Chiefs all agreed that we needed to pull out by August 31 – based on the
Doha agreement, which former President Trump had signed with the Taliban in
early 2020, which had NO participation by the Afghan government, and which required
a total withdrawal of all foreign forces.
Milley testified that if U.S. troops had stayed beyond August, then the
Taliban would have resumed the fighting and, in order to stave off the attacks adding:
“We would have needed 30,000 troops and
would have suffered many casualties.”
Milley also testified that
he, all the Joint Chiefs, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, and other officers had
all advised President Joe Biden to keep 2,500 U.S. troops in Afghanistan beyond
the August 31 deadline.
Milley added that the difference would be: “That those remaining troops wouldn’t be attached to or given any military
mission, instead they would transition to a diplomatic mission. It was extremely
unlikely that the Taliban would have observed the semantic distinction.”
In the Taliban’s eyes, the
remaining 2,500 U.S. troops would be seen as 2,500 U.S. troops, regardless of
their “diplomatic or military label.”
The fighting would have been
fierce.
Milley said the Taliban would resume more fighting, as Milley said
they would, and Biden would then have been faced with two horrendous choices:
“(1) To pull out while under attack, or
(2) Send in another 30,000 American troops.”
Some
historical-psychological perspective is worth noting. In the first nine
months of Barack Obama’s presidency, the generals were pushing for a major
escalation of the war in Afghanistan — an increase of 40,000 troops — and a
shift to a counterinsurgency (AKA: “Nation-building” strategy).
Biden, who was then vice
president, was alone in suggesting an increase of just 10,000 troops, to be
used solely for training the Afghan army and for fighting terrorists along the
Afghan-Pakistani border.
As Obama recalls in
his memoir, Biden urged the new and relatively inexperienced president
not to be “boxed in by the generals” saying in essence: “Give them 40,000 troops now, and in 18
months, they’ll say they need another 40,000 to win the war.”
Mr. Obama later acknowledged that Joe Biden
was right.
Likewise, as Gen. Milley was advising President Biden to
keep 2,500 troops in Afghanistan, even while acknowledging that another 30,000
might be needed if the Taliban resumed fighting.
It’s easy to imagine President
Biden’s thinking: “They’re trying to
box me in, just like they did before, just like they’ve always done since the
Vietnam War,” (which BTW was raging when Biden first entered the Senate in
1973 and has shaped his views on war and peace ever since).
THE NBC NEWS STORY NOW CONTINUES:
It is not clear, though, what would legally justify “treason” charges since the military officers were following the orders of President Joe Biden to withdraw all U.S. forces from Afghanistan.
Further,
the 2022 independent review by the Special IG
(Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction) blamed both the Trump and
Biden administrations for the chaotic U.S. withdrawal in 2021.
More Historical Facts: Trump first reached an agreement with the Taliban in 2020 to withdraw all U.S. forces from Afghanistan, roughly 13,000 troops, and release 5,000 Taliban fighters from prison.
The Biden administration then completed the
withdrawal and badly overestimated the ability of Afghan government forces to
fight the Taliban on their own.
Now, Trump’s choice for Defense Secretary is FOX News personality Pete Hegseth, who has
criticized the withdrawal, saying the U.S. lost the war and wasted billions of
dollars.
Hegseth wrote in his book: The War on Warriors the following: “The next president of the United States needs to radically overhaul Pentagon senior leadership to make us ready to defend our nation and defeat our enemies. Lots of people need to be fired. The debacle in Afghanistan, of course, is the most glaring example.”
Hegseth goes on to call
the withdrawal a “humiliating retreat” and says leaders at the Pentagon were
not held accountable for the deadly attack at Abbey Gate, which killed 13 U.S. service
members and roughly 170 Afghan civilians. Nor were they held accountable for a
subsequent U.S. airstrike in Kabul that officials thought would kill the
Islamic State group leader behind the suicide attack but instead killed 10
innocent Afghans, including seven children.
Hegseth continued: “These generals lied. They mismanaged.
They violated their oath. They failed. They disgraced our troops, and our
nation. They got people killed, unnecessarily. And, to this moment, they keep
their jobs. Worse, they continue to actively erode our military and its values
— by capitulating to civilians with radical agendas. They are an embarrassment,
with stars still on their shoulders.”
The transition team is looking at the possibility of
recalling several commanders to active duty for possible charges. It’s not
clear the Trump administration would pursue treason charges, and instead could
focus on lesser charges that highlight the officer’s involvement.
Speaking to NBC News days before the 2024 election, Howard Lutnick, one of the two advisers leading the transition, said: “Trump learned after his first administration that he had hired Democratic generals, and he would not make that mistake again.”
Former officials who worked in Trump’s first administration
have said they advised Trump against policies they thought would weaken U.S.
national security, such as withdrawing U.S. troops from Syria.
They also advised him against actions that they thought
might violate the Constitution or inflame tensions domestically, such as
deploying active-duty U.S. troops to quell protests after the 2020 police
killing of George Floyd.
My 2 Cents: The Trump
nominees thus far and now this one in particular ups the ante on insanity even
more so just like this quote often attributed to Albert Einstein: “Insanity is
doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” But,
Einstein did not say it or originate it, either.
ORIGIN: The quote was
originally attributed to a fictional character named Jane Fulton in Rita Mae
Brown's 1983 book “Sudden Death.”
THE ACTUAL CREDIT: The
quote is actually credited to sociology professor William Bruce Cameron, who
included it in a 1963 textbook and a couple of articles.
Einstein wasn't associated
with the quote until the mid-1980s, but carries more weight, I suppose?
Now with Trump today
wanting to go after and nail officers re: the Afghanistan debacle, why not go
back to the U.S. withdrawal in VN that gave North Vietnam the entire country.
Or, go back to our own
Civil War with President Lincoln and famous Generals and their decisions?
That my friends is true insanity don’t you think?
I say again, the facts matter always, but apparently not in
MAGA world?
Thanks for stopping by.